Categories
Law Students and Young Lawyers

A Cheery AI Goodbye to Your Law Firm

Here is a version of a departure announcement that a lawyer recently posted on LinkedIn, which I have rewritten slightly to recast it as if he were getting divorced:

“After three years of growth, learning and development with my excellent wife, today I close out an important and rewarding chapter in my life.

I am truly grateful for the opportunities I have had and experience I have gained with my wife and her family, who have helped make this portion of my journey so impactful. I leave this marriage a better person than when I met my wife, and that is solely a result of her and her fantastic family and friends who I had the pleasure to interact with over my time in this wonderful marriage.

While it is never easy to say goodbye to an amazing family, I am excited for my next chapter and the challenges that lie ahead.

I eagerly look forward to announcing my next domestic adventure shortly. Stay tuned.”

If the departing lawyer is sincere, I am hard-pressed to imagine for what possible reason he might be leaving his firm.

Or maybe “he doth protest too much,” and his experience was not as awe-inspiring as he has tried to convey.

And what is with the “cliffhanger” that hints at a great future but never says what the person is going to be doing next?

It might be that the delighted departing lawyer has no idea where he is going, in which case he was either fired or so miserable or underpaid that he quit. That would make his whole announcement disingenuous.

More likely, he has a much better situation waiting for him, but he did not want to include that in the divorce announcement, because it would make his cheery goodbye look insincere.

I understand that well-brought-up young lawyers might believe “that if you have nothing nice to say, don’t say anything at all.” But these happy-go-lucky lawyers are skipping merrily out of their firms saying wonderful things, so there must be more to it. Perhaps it has to do with not burning bridges.

Personally, I think that it is yet another example of people following the current flavour of the month spit out by AI. To test that theory, I asked ChatGPT to draft a departure notice for a third-year lawyer. It read much like this lawyer’s announcement, and included the following:

“After three incredible years at [law firm name], it’s time for my next chapter.

Reflecting on my time here, I am deeply grateful for the opportunities, challenges and growth I’ve experienced. Over the past three years, I’ve had the privilege of working alongside exceptionally talented colleagues, tackling complex legal matters and advocating for wonderful clients.

A huge thank you to my mentors, partners and team members who guided, challenged and supported me along the way. The lessons learned and relationships built here will undoubtedly shape the rest of my career.

Stay tuned for updates on what’s next!”

Am I the only one who is not buying this bunch of malarkey?

This article was originally published by Law360 Canada, part of LexisNexis Canada Inc

Categories
Mental Health and Work/Life Balance

How Plain Old Bad Luck Ruins Law Firms

There is an old story about a farmer who was training his horse to eat less food so that he could increase his profits. He gradually reduced the amount of feed that he gave the horse, until it was eating a small fraction of what horses usually eat. He was on the verge of a breakthrough and had visions of patenting his methodology and becoming both famous and fabulously wealthy.

Categories
The Practice of Law

Rich or Poor, It’s Good to Have Money (Leverage in Negotiations)

The first part of the title of this article is a quote from my mother, who has repeated these words as far back as I can remember. However, my minimalist effort to conduct research before I write stuff uncovered that the quote is attributed to some fellow named Alan Sheinwald. I really don’t know who stole it from who. But, as Mr. Hayes, my grade nine math teacher, used to say, “it makes no never mind.”

Categories
People I Met Practicing Law

Rich People Have Problems Too

I articled for the now defunct law firm of Goodman and Carr. It was a well-regarded firm in its day. Wolfe Goodman was a senior partner and a leading tax lawyer of his era. In my tax rotation, I spent considerable time with him. He made tax sound so interesting that there was even a brief moment in time that I thought I wanted to be a tax lawyer.

Categories
Law Students and Young Lawyers

The Benefit of Being Sane in the Legal Profession

Newly qualified lawyers are not known for being mature, confident, well-rounded, and psychologically sound. And why should we expect them to be? Most of them are young, having just emerged from years of student life. Few have had a significant prior career. They have likely graduated, with substantial debt, from schools that have not adequately trained them to practice law.

Categories
Legal Tech

What I learned About Artificial Intelligence in the 1990’s

My firm had a thriving real estate practice in the 1980’s. When the real estate market tanked from 1989 until about 1996, they were not happy times. We did not hire any real estate lawyers in those days.

Categories
Mental Health and Work/Life Balance

Macro Marvellous, Micro Miserable

Bob told me about his law firm exit interview with Joan from H.R. When Bob said that he was leaving due to the unreasonable workload, Joan was curious, because Bob was one of several associates who had left that department for the same reason. What surprised Joan was that in other departments, the associates were working many more hours, but no one was complaining, let alone quitting.

Categories
Mental Health and Work/Life Balance

The Law 360 Canada Pulse Survey: Murray Says WHAAAAAT?


The good folks at Law 360 have produced their annual survey of what lawyers think about their profession.

Here is the part that I don’t get.

60% of Associates (and 44%) of partners say that they either feel stressed most of the time or all of the time.

At the same time, 63% report being satisfied, or very satisfied, with their jobs.

So, let me get this straight. Lawyers are generally happy with their jobs, while being stressed most or all of the time.

I am reminded of the famous quote from The Princess Bride: “You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.”

Maybe I am an outlier, but I am usually happiest when I am not stressed about things like getting my work done on time, meeting billable hour requirements, or getting sued. But that’s just me.

Categories
Mental Health and Work/Life Balance

Deny, Deny, Deny – Right Up to the Breakdown

“Denial ain’t just a river in Egypt.”  

~ Mark Twain

I was speaking to a mom of three children the other day. She drives them to their different schools every morning and ferries them to sports activities after school and on the weekends, while trying to advance her career in the remaining time. She was talking about how difficult it was to stay on top of everything and take care of her own health, but she was pleased that she was somehow managing it all. My response? “Sure, right up to the breakdown.”

Categories
Legal Tech

A.I. is No Substitute for a Determined Soul

My wife likes to tell the story of the first file that she worked on for me when she articled for my firm. (Those were in the days when she did what I told her to do, because I was the boss. Things have changed.)

I had her work on a financing file. Back in the day, financing statements under the Personal Property Security Act were typed on a government form, and submitted over the counter.